Milly – Brook McGinnis
Adam – Eric Browne
Gideon – Danny Moore
Benjamin –Anthony Wildfong
Caleb – T.J. Medley
Daniel – Alan Hood
Ephraim – Ross Madak
Frank – Seth Lund
Alice – Tarah Malek
Dorcas – Holli Isom
Ruth – Magan Guthrie
Liza – Kristy McCutcheon
Martha – Cassie King
Sarah – Sarah Barnett
Jeb – Josh Ballew
Luke – Justin Ennis
Carl – Justin Bradley
Matt – Paul Powers
Joel – Rocky Jex
Zeke – Nathaniel Wallace
Preacher – Marcus McSpadden
Mr. Bixby – Wes Lund
Mrs. Bixby – Tabitha Childers
Mr. Perkins – Dustin Hollaway
Mrs. Perkins – Linsi Adams
Sister – Whitney Snow

Townspeople – Josh Eason, Anna Beth Harbison, Telisha Montgomery, Holly Kelley, Kyndal Shipp, Jennifer McWhorter, Amy Barnett, Andrea Tidmore