Milly – Brook McGinnis

Adam – Eric Browne

Gideon – Danny Moore

Benjamin –Anthony Wildfong

Caleb – T.J. Medley

Daniel – Alan Hood

Ephraim – Ross Madak

Frank – Seth Lund

Alice – Tarah Malek

Dorcas – Holli Isom

Ruth – Magan Guthrie

Liza – Kristy McCutcheon

Martha – Cassie King

Sarah – Sarah Barnett

Jeb – Josh Ballew

Luke – Justin Ennis

Carl – Justin Bradley

Matt – Paul Powers

Joel – Rocky Jex

Zeke – Nathaniel Wallace

Preacher – Marcus McSpadden

Mr. Bixby – Wes Lund

Mrs. Bixby – Tabitha Childers

Mr. Perkins – Dustin Hollaway

Mrs. Perkins – Linsi Adams

Sister – Whitney Snow

Townspeople – Josh Eason, Anna Beth Harbison, Telisha Montgomery, Holly Kelley, Kyndal Shipp, Jennifer McWhorter, Amy Barnett, Andrea Tidmore